Knowledge

Fed-Batch Feeding: How a Controlled Diet Builds Cell Density and Yield

Fed-batch cultivation means the carbon source is not all added at the start. It is fed in over time, so the culture grows under substrate limitation instead of in excess. Nutrient-limited fed-batch technology is the standard for cultivating microorganisms and producing heterologous proteins in industry, because of its advantages for metabolic control and high cell density growth [2]. Recombinant protein production processes in Escherichia coli are usually operated in fed-batch mode [6].

The reason is simple: what you feed, and how fast, sets the specific growth rate. The growth rate in turn sets how much biomass you accumulate, how the host responds to the burden of making a foreign protein, and how much of the product ends up soluble and correctly folded.

The feed sets the growth rate, and the growth rate sets the product

A controlled diet does more than pack more cells into the vessel. Reviewing ready-made media that release glucose biocatalytically from a polymer, Krause and colleagues report that the controlled diet not only gives significantly higher cell yields, but that in many cases folding of the target protein is improved by the lower growth rates imposed — so the final volumetric yield of active protein can be a multiple of what a complex-medium culture gives [2]. The same review notes that these systems improved product yield, culture robustness and cell densities together [2].

This is the trade-off a process engineer is actually tuning. Feeding faster gives faster growth; it does not automatically give more usable product. In a Pichia pastoris process expressing a Rhizopus oryzae lipase, transcriptional levels of genes linked to the unfolded protein response and to central metabolism were generally higher at higher growth rates in fed-batch cultivations [3]. The authors report that overexpression and secretion of the lipase appeared to trigger the unfolded protein response — the cell's reaction to protein that is not folding properly in the secretory pathway — and that this acted as a physiological bottleneck for the production process [3]. Pushing the feed harder can push the host into exactly the stress state that limits output.

Strain choice and feed profile are one decision, not two

The same feeding regime does not treat every host the same way. Marisch and colleagues directly compared three T7-based expression hosts — E. coli BL21(DE3), RV308(DE3) and HMS174(DE3) — in exponential carbon-limited fed-batch cultivation on minimal media with single-pulse induction, producing recombinant human superoxide dismutase as a model protein [1].

  • BL21(DE3) produced the highest amounts of specific protein, followed by HMS174(DE3) and RV308(DE3) [1].
  • HMS174(DE3) retained the expression vector over the entire process time, showing system stability — but it stopped growing entirely shortly after induction [1].
  • BL21(DE3) and RV308(DE3) encountered plasmid loss, yet kept growing [1].
  • RV308(DE3) showed the lowest ppGpp concentration, which correlates with metabolic stress level, and the lowest degradation of the soluble protein fraction of the three [1].

The authors present this as data to enable targeted strain selection for a specific protein of interest, and to accelerate process design and implementation [1]. Read alongside the growth-rate findings, the point is that "highest titre" and "most stable" were different strains in the same experiment [1].

Getting the feed profile without a long campaign

For methanol-induced P. pastoris processes, Dietzsch and colleagues describe a fast way to get the parameters a feed profile needs. Their approach quantifies a minimal set of bioprocess-relevant parameters — the adaptation time of the culture to methanol, the specific substrate uptake rate during the adaptation phase, and the maximum specific substrate uptake rate — from easy-to-do batch cultivations with repeated methanol pulses [4].

Their detailed analysis found that each strain behaved very differently during adaptation to methanol, which the authors take as evidence that individual screening is needed to define parameters optimally for that phase [4]. Dynamic feeding profiles were then built on the specific substrate uptake rate for several strains, and the maximum specific uptake rate determined in batch also represented the upper limit of methanol uptake in fed-batch — so profiles could be designed without running the risk of methanol accumulation [4]. Substrate accumulation is the failure mode a feed profile exists to prevent.

Screen in fed-batch, or screen the wrong thing

Most development lines screen in batch and only then build the fed-batch process [5]. Working on a difficult-to-express RNase inhibitor, they found the crucial factors for high target protein yield were the fusion partner, the use of a mineral salt medium together with the fed-batch technique, and the preinduction growth rate [5]. The conditions favoured in microwell plate and shake flask scales also worked in the bioreactor [5]. Their blunter finding: in that case, standard batch cultures failed to select the right clone or conditions at all [5].

Toeroek and colleagues developed a reproducible fed-batch-like microtitre plate protocol for E. coli in a micro-bioreactor with online monitoring [6]. A synthetic enzymatic glucose release medium supplied carbon-limited growth without any external feed and provided the buffer capacity to hold pH within 7 ± 1 [6]. Process design allowed cultivation up to 10 g biomass per litre with no oxygen limitation, dissolved oxygen staying above 30 % [6]. Growth, dissolved oxygen and pH were monitored online, and the authors evaluated cultivation temperature, applicability to different host strains and transferability to lab-scale bioreactor cultivations [6]. Difficulty and expense in applying a controlled continuous glucose feed to shaken cultures is precisely why batch remained the laboratory default [2].

Beyond microbial protein

The same logic is applied outside recombinant protein work. High productivity in CHO cell culture relies on optimised culture medium management under fed-batch or perfused chemostat strategies enabling high cell densities [7]. A dynamic metabolic model calibrated against two batch and two fed-batch CHO cultures on two different media simulated viable cell behaviour in all cases with a single parameter set, and dynamic metabolic flux analysis indicated the media and fed-batch strategies tested had little impact on flux distribution [7]. In engineered E. coli, an optimised fed-batch fermentation yielded a titre of 922 mg L⁻¹ fatty acid ethyl esters [8].

What to take from this

When assessing a process or a process-transfer partner, ask where the feed profile came from. A defensible answer names the parameters it was built on — adaptation time and specific substrate uptake rates, determined per strain [4] — rather than a generic exponential ramp. Ask at which scale the clone and the conditions were selected, because conditions chosen in batch may not reproduce in fed-batch at all [5], while fed-batch-like microtitre protocols have been shown to transfer to lab-scale bioreactors [5][6]. And ask what the chosen growth rate costs: higher growth rates raised unfolded protein response markers in P. pastoris [3], while lower growth rates under controlled feeding improved folding in E. coli systems [2].

References

  1. Marisch K, Bayer K, Cserjan-Puschmann M, Luchner M, Striedner G. Evaluation of three industrial Escherichia coli strains in fed-batch cultivations during high-level SOD protein production — Microbial cell factories, 2013-06-11.
  2. Krause M, Neubauer A, Neubauer P. The fed-batch principle for the molecular biology lab: controlled nutrient diets in ready-made media improve production of recombinant proteins in Escherichia coli — Microbial cell factories, 2016-06-17.
  3. Resina D, Bollók M, Khatri NK, Valero F, Neubauer P, Ferrer P. Transcriptional response of P. pastoris in fed-batch cultivations to Rhizopus oryzae lipase production reveals UPR induction — Microbial cell factories, 2007-07-16.
  4. Dietzsch C, Spadiut O, Herwig C. A fast approach to determine a fed batch feeding profile for recombinant Pichia pastoris strains — Microbial cell factories, 2011-10-27.
  5. Siurkus J, Panula-Perälä J, Horn U, Kraft M, Rimseliene R, Neubauer P. Novel approach of high cell density recombinant bioprocess development: optimisation and scale-up from microliter to pilot scales while maintaining the fed-batch cultivation mode of E. coli cultures — Microbial cell factories, 2010-05-20.
  6. Toeroek C, Cserjan-Puschmann M, Bayer K, Striedner G. Fed-batch like cultivation in a micro-bioreactor: screening conditions relevant for Escherichia coli based production processes — SpringerPlus, 2015-09-11.
  7. Robitaille J, Chen J, Jolicoeur M. A Single Dynamic Metabolic Model Can Describe mAb Producing CHO Cell Batch and Fed-Batch Cultures on Different Culture Media — PloS one, 2015-09-02.
  8. Duan Y, Zhu Z, Cai K, Tan X, Lu X. De novo biosynthesis of biodiesel by Escherichia coli in optimized fed-batch cultivation — PloS one, 2011-05-23.

All articles