Chromatography Step by Step: How Published Protocols Purify Recombinant Proteins
Chromatography is the part of a recombinant protein process where the target is separated from everything else the host cell made. A fermentation delivers the protein mixed with host proteins, nucleic acids, media components and variants of the target itself. Chromatography is how that mixture is reduced to one substance of known composition. The published protocols below, covering histones, human growth hormone, a fungal lipase, an archaeal β-galactosidase, an algal hydrogenase, a plant dehydrogenase and α-synuclein, show that only a handful of separation modes are in regular use — and that the interesting decisions are about order, starting material and how the result is checked.
What comes before the column decides what the column has to do
The feed into the first column is set by whether the protein is soluble in the cell, locked into insoluble aggregates, or secreted into the medium.
When high-level expression in Escherichia coli drives the protein into inclusion bodies — dense insoluble aggregates that lack biological activity — the usual answer is to recover and refold them. For recombinant human growth hormone, one group took the opposite route: they minimised inclusion body formation in the first place and optimised purification conditions, so that most of the total protein ended up in the soluble fraction, which was then purified in high yield by a series of chromatographic procedures [4].
A second approach keeps the inclusion bodies but skips their isolation. A streamlined protocol for recombinant histones from bacteria, which the authors call "rapid histone purification", prepares whole cell extracts under strongly denaturing conditions that directly solubilise the inclusion bodies, cutting out what the authors describe as the most time-consuming step of traditional protocols [3]. The histones are then purified from those extracts by ion exchange chromatography [3]. Histones prepared this way and histones purified from isolated inclusion bodies had similar purities, and the two strategies did not affect the quality of the octamers reconstituted from them [3].
Where the host secretes the protein, the first operation is concentration rather than lysis. A pro-form Rhizopus oryzae lipase expressed and secreted in Pichia pastoris was produced by fed-batch cultivation in a 50-L bioreactor with methanol induction, reaching 21,000 U/mL after 168 h [7]. The supernatant was concentrated by ultrafiltration through a 10 kDa cut-off membrane, then purified by ion exchange chromatography on SP Sepharose Fast Flow [7].
Ion exchange: the usual first column
Ion exchange separates by net surface charge, and it appears as the capture step in most of these protocols. The histone protocol used ion exchange directly on denatured whole-cell extract [3]. For α-synuclein from E. coli , all four of the compared isolation routes — boiling, acid precipitation, ammonium sulfate precipitation and periplasmic lysis — were followed by ion exchange chromatography and gel filtration [5].
A plant enzyme shows how far ion exchange alone can be pushed. Farnesol dehydrogenase from Polygonum minus leaves was purified 204-fold to apparent homogeneity by ion-exchange chromatography on DEAE-Toyopearl, SP-Toyopearl and Super-Q Toyopearl, followed by three successive gel filtration runs on TSK-gel GS3000SW [8]. That is three different ion exchange chemistries in series — an anion exchanger, a cation exchanger and another anion exchanger — before any size step. The purified enzyme was a heterodimer of 65 kDa and 70 kDa subunits [8].
Affinity and fusion tags: engineering the separation into the molecule
Affinity chromatography binds the target through a specific interaction rather than a bulk property, and a fusion partner can be chosen to create that interaction. For the algal [FeFe]-hydrogenase HydA1, a fusion was built with the [2Fe2S]-ferredoxin PetF [6]. Placing the ferredoxin at the N-terminus rather than the C-terminus gave expression levels four-fold higher [6].
The fusion did double duty. The strong binding affinity of the ferredoxin for DEAE allowed a two-step purification by ion exchange followed by StrepTactin affinity chromatography [6]. A TEV protease site in the linker between the two parts let the ferredoxin be removed proteolytically after the DEAE step, so that the hydrogenase alone could then be purified on StrepTactin [6]. The combined process gave yields of 5 mg of HydA1 per litre of E. coli culture with specific activities of 1000 U [6].
That work also names a failure mode specific to metalloenzymes: low fidelity of the complex, enzyme-specific post-translational maturation process leaves a significant fraction of inactive apo-protein in the preparation, which is not suitable for biophysical or crystallographic study [6]. Chromatography that separates on charge or size will not necessarily separate mature from apo forms.
Hydrophobic interaction and gel filtration as polishing steps
Hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) separates on exposed hydrophobic surface. A recombinant β-galactosidase from the Antarctic haloarchaeon Halorubrum lacusprofundi, expressed in Halobacterium sp. NRC-1 under a cold shock protein gene promoter at 20-fold higher levels than in the native organism, was purified using gel filtration and hydrophobic interaction chromatography [2]. It was then identified by SDS-PAGE, LC-MS/MS and ONPG hydrolysis activity [2].
HIC also works as an analytical tool. A review in mAbs describes HIC-HPLC as a method for separating molecular variants of therapeutic proteins, used to monitor post-translational modifications including proteolytic fragments and domain misfolding, tryptophan oxidation, aspartic acid isomerisation, cyclic imide formation, α-amidated carboxy termini, carboxy-terminal heterogeneity and serine fucosylation [1]. The same review discusses critical method parameters and suitability for operation in a regulated environment [1]. In other words, the same chemistry that polishes a preparative stream can be run analytically to show which variants the preparative stream still contains.
The purity you get depends on the route you took
The α-synuclein comparison is the clearest evidence that purification choices are not interchangeable. Using nondenaturing electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry, the authors found that material isolated by acid precipitation and by periplasmic lysis was the purest and gave the highest proportion of monomeric protein — 100% and 96.5% respectively [5]. Material from the different protocols behaved differently in cells, with the more multimeric and degraded, least pure samples producing a larger increase in cell vitality [5]. Notably, purity and monomer content did not correlate with aggregation propensity [5]. The authors' conclusion is that the choice of purification method can significantly influence the outcome of a subsequent study [5].
Checking the result
None of these protocols stops at the last column. The growth hormone work analysed the purified material by reversed-phase HPLC, size-exclusion chromatography, MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry and circular dichroism, and concluded on that combined basis that the protein was highly pure, of the expected molecular mass and with intact secondary structure [4]. The β-galactosidase was confirmed by SDS-PAGE, LC-MS/MS and an activity assay [2]. The farnesol dehydrogenase was characterised down to the sequences of four tryptic peptides by MALDI-TOF/TOF-MS, which showed no significant similarity to previously reported farnesol dehydrogenases [8].
What to take from this when choosing a process
Three practical points follow from the evidence.
When comparing processes or suppliers, ask which chromatography modes are in the train and in what order, what the feed into the first column is, and which analytical methods establish that the final material is what it is claimed to be. A protocol that reports only a yield figure has not answered the question.
References
- Haverick M, Mengisen S, Shameem M, Ambrogelly A. Separation of mAbs molecular variants by analytical hydrophobic interaction chromatography HPLC: overview and applications — mAbs, 2014-07-01.
- Karan R, Capes MD, DasSarma P, DasSarma S. Cloning, overexpression, purification, and characterization of a polyextremophilic β-galactosidase from the Antarctic haloarchaeon Halorubrum lacusprofundi — BMC biotechnology, 2013-01-16.
- Klinker H, Haas C, Harrer N, Becker PB, Mueller-Planitz F. Rapid purification of recombinant histones — PloS one, 2014-08-04.
- Kim MJ, Park HS, Seo KH, Yang HJ, Kim SK, Choi JH. Complete solubilization and purification of recombinant human growth hormone produced in Escherichia coli — PloS one, 2013-02-07.
- Stephens AD, Matak-Vinkovic D, Fernandez-Villegas A, Kaminski Schierle GS. Purification of Recombinant α-synuclein: A Comparison of Commonly Used Protocols — Biochemistry, 2020-11-25.
- Yacoby I, Tegler LT, Pochekailov S, Zhang S, King PW. Optimized expression and purification for high-activity preparations of algal [FeFe]-hydrogenase — PloS one, 2012-04-26.
- Wang JR, Li YY, Xu SD, Li P, Liu JS, Liu DN. High-level expression of pro-form lipase from Rhizopus oryzae in Pichia pastoris and its purification and characterization — International journal of molecular sciences, 2013-12-24.
- Ahmad-Sohdi NA, Seman-Kamarulzaman AF, Mohamed-Hussein ZA, Hassan M. Purification and Characterization of a Novel NAD(P)+-Farnesol Dehydrogenase from Polygonum minus Leaves — PloS one, 2015-11-23.

