Knowledge

Making a Protein in E. coli: Host Strain, Gene Design and Yield

Before a recombinant peptide or protein can be purified, it has to be made. In a bacterial process that means putting a gene for the target into Escherichia coli — a fast-growing bacterium used as a production cell — and growing the cells until they have filled themselves with the product. Everything downstream, from how much cell paste you have to handle to whether the molecule needs refolding, is decided at this step.

The published reviews are consistent about why E. coli is the default. It is described as one of the organisms of choice for recombinant protein production and a widely used expression platform, supported by a large catalogue of expression plasmids, many engineered strains and many cultivation strategies [1]. A second review lists the same reasons more concretely: relative simplicity, inexpensive and fast high-density cultivation, well-known genetics, and a large number of compatible molecular tools [2].

The host is a choice, not a given

The clearest documented example is disulfide bonding. A disulfide bond is a covalent link between two cysteine residues that holds a folded protein in shape. Both eukaryotic and prokaryotic organisms keep their cytoplasm reduced, so disulfide bond formation is impaired in that compartment [5]. Eukaryotic cells form these bonds in the oxidising environment of the endoplasmic reticulum during export; bacteria have no equivalent compartment, but they do have export systems and enzymatic activities for forming and quality-controlling disulfide bonds in the oxidising periplasm [5]. Producing correctly disulfide-bonded proteins to high yields is described as a continuing challenge, and few strains are dedicated to post-translational modifications such as disulfide bond formation [3].

One engineered answer is the SHuffle strain, built on a trxB gor suppressor background in which the cytoplasmic reductive pathways have been diminished so that disulfide bonds can form in the cytoplasm, with a signal-sequenceless disulfide bond isomerase, DsbC, integrated into the chromosome [3]. In the characterisation work on that strain, the B strain background outperformed the K12 version, and co-expression of mutant thioredoxins and PDI homologs improved yields of various substrate proteins [3]. That is a useful reminder for anyone comparing process routes: two strains carrying the same plasmid are not interchangeable.

The gene sequence itself sets the ceiling

Synthetic genes are increasingly used for protein production because sequence information is easier to obtain than the corresponding physical DNA, and coding sequences are commonly re-designed to raise expression [4]. The systematic test of that practice is worth knowing in detail.

Sets of synthetic genes were made for expression in E. coli, encoding a DNA polymerase and a single-chain antibody [4]. The genes within each set differed only in synonymous codon usage — same protein, different DNA spelling. Expression ranged from undetectable to 30% of cellular protein [4]. The amount of protein produced depended strongly on the codons used to encode a subset of amino acids, and the favourable codons were predominantly those read by tRNAs that are most highly charged during amino acid starvation, not the codons most abundant in highly expressed E. coli proteins [4]. The authors then designed, synthesised and tested new genes using codon biases their models predicted would perform well, and confirmed the models [4]. They concluded that codon usage within a gene is a critical determinant of achievable expression levels, and proposed that the same methodology could be used to derive design algorithms for any expression system [4].

Two practical points follow. First, a disappointing titre may be a sequence problem rather than a fermentation problem. Second, the common shortcut of matching codon frequencies to the host's most highly expressed genes was not what correlated with yield in this study [4].

Plasmid, promoter and induction

The plasmid carries the gene and the genetic parts that switch it on. The pET series is widely used for recombinant protein production in E. coli; its transcription and translation modules were first described in the 1980s and had not changed since [7]. One group reported design flaws in those modules, presented improved designs, and showed that incorporating them into pET28a supported increases in protein production — changes applicable to most of the 103 vectors in the series and easy to implement [7].

Induction — the moment you tell the cells to start making product — can also be done by temperature. The system based on the phage lambda pL and/or pR promoters regulated by the thermolabile cI857 repressor has been widely used in prokaryotic cells, with induction achieved by raising culture temperature, generally above 37 °C [8]. The review of that system stresses that the temperature up-shift triggers a variety of complex stress responses alongside the overexpression itself, and that relatively few studies discuss those simultaneous effects; understanding them is presented as the route to improved strategies for high-yield production and recovery [8]. Culture operation variables and induction strategies are named among the bioprocessing factors that affect overexpression [8].

Temperature matters even when it is not the inducer. In the SHuffle optimisation work, expression conditions were varied across temperature, induction conditions, strain background and co-expressed helper proteins, and temperature had the biggest impact on improving yields; auto-expression of target proteins in that strain gave higher yields of active pure protein [3].

The usual failure mode

Despite all of the above, expression in E. coli often results in insoluble and/or non-functional protein [2]. The reviewed strategies to avoid it split into two families: controlled expression of the target in an unmodified form, and modification of the construct using expressivity and solubility tags [2]. The physiological features of bacteria are also noted as a limit on producing, in native form, polypeptides that undergo extensive post-translational modification [5].

One further route sidesteps the living cell. Cell-free E. coli systems normally use bacteriophage RNA polymerases such as T7 [6]. A system using only the endogenous E. coli RNA polymerase and sigma factor 70 produced roughly 0.75 mg/ml of Firefly luciferase and enhanced green fluorescent protein in batch mode, with the plasmid optimised using different regulatory parts and a re-engineered, more translatable eGFP [6]. Of three ATP regeneration systems tested — creatine phosphate, phosphoenolpyruvate and 3-phosphoglyceric acid — the maximum protein production came with 3-PGA, and crude extract preparation was streamlined to a 12-hour routine including cell culture [6].

What to ask about a process

When you evaluate a bacterial route for a peptide or protein, the evidence suggests four questions. Which strain background, and was it chosen for a reason such as disulfide bond formation [3][5]? Which plasmid and which induction mode, and were the regulatory parts examined rather than inherited [7][8]? And how much of the product is soluble, since insoluble or non-functional protein is the expected outcome often enough that whole reviews exist about avoiding it [2]. A process that can answer all four has been developed; one that cannot has been copied.

References

  1. Rosano GL, Ceccarelli EA. Recombinant protein expression in Escherichia coli: advances and challenges — Frontiers in microbiology, 2014-04-17.
  2. Sørensen HP, Mortensen KK. Soluble expression of recombinant proteins in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli — Microbial cell factories, 2005-01-04.
  3. Lobstein J, Emrich CA, Jeans C, Faulkner M, Riggs P, Berkmen M. SHuffle, a novel Escherichia coli protein expression strain capable of correctly folding disulfide bonded proteins in its cytoplasm — Microbial cell factories, 2012-05-08.
  4. Welch M, Govindarajan S, Ness JE, Villalobos A, Gurney A, Minshull J, Gustafsson C. Design parameters to control synthetic gene expression in Escherichia coli — PloS one, 2009-09-14.
  5. de Marco A. Strategies for successful recombinant expression of disulfide bond-dependent proteins in Escherichia coli — Microbial cell factories, 2009-05-14.
  6. Shin J, Noireaux V. Efficient cell-free expression with the endogenous E. Coli RNA polymerase and sigma factor 70 — Journal of biological engineering, 2010-06-24.
  7. Shilling PJ, Mirzadeh K, Cumming AJ, Widesheim M, Köck Z, Daley DO. Improved designs for pET expression plasmids increase protein production yield in Escherichia coli — Communications biology, 2020-05-07.
  8. Valdez-Cruz NA, Caspeta L, Pérez NO, Ramírez OT, Trujillo-Roldán MA. Production of recombinant proteins in E. coli by the heat inducible expression system based on the phage lambda pL and/or pR promoters — Microbial cell factories, 2010-03-19.

All articles